Barefoot Monologues

A Journey of the Sole

Review: VIVOBAREFOOT Breatho Trail

31 Comments

So far I have put two runs and 24 miles on my VIVOBAREFOOT Breathos. As you can see by the amount of dirt on them in the photos, they have been rugged miles – full of dirt, mud, pond scum, horse poop and heavy brush (I have a small bladder, and spend a good deal of time off the path).

Actually, that’s not true. I’ve put more like 27 miles on the Breathos. I first wore them walking my dog on the trails right by my house. I decided to wear them walking first because I wasn’t sure how they were going to fit and I didn’t want any surprises to end my next trail run abruptly. Why? Because my first thought as I took them out of the box was, “Crap. They’re kind of narrow.” I compared them to my Neo Trails. There is a definite difference. And being as sensitive to the width of shoes as I am, this could have been a problem.

Width difference: Neo Trail on left, Breatho on right.

But as soon as I wore them walking, I learned why the slight difference in width is there. The upper of the Breathos are made from a really thin mesh rather than the much thicker padded mesh of the Neo Trail, making the extra sole width unnecessary. Once I started to walk in them it all clicked: the mesh is stretchy. Stretchy mesh makes anything feel looser (just look at skinny jeans, or the Vibram SeeYa).

With that little mystery solved, it was time to take these babies out for a spin.

Looks

Like most footwear companies, VIVOBAREFOOT has a pretty consistent stylistic theme to its products. The look is classic, a bit retro and not necessarily as “sporty” as what you would typically find out there in the running shoe world. The one superficial comment that I have about Vivo’s styling in general is that most of their shoes seem to look more jeans and t-shirt than running tights and sports bra. Sparsely styled, block coloring, roomy and shapeless lasts. But that’s not so much a criticism as it is an observation.

With that said, the Breathos are the sexiest shoe in Vivo’s athletic line. At first glance they look just like everything else Vivo makes, but they’re much sleeker, leaner. They remind me of the Minimus Trail that NewBalance makes (which I can’t even get my feet into, otherwise I would have reviewed them) – rugged, curvy and perhaps a little showy. The Minimus has so far been my pick for the best looking minimalist shoe. The Breatho has that same edge. It has better lines and much more shape than some of Vivo’s other offerings, making it a shoe that’s just as beautiful as it is functional. As a consumer and a designer, I know this is extremely important to the success of a product.

The only suggestion I would make on the looks front is to add more colors. The only color ways they offer at the moment for women are pink, blue and black, while the men’s styles always seem to have more and better color choices. Really? Most men don’t spend three seconds making a color choice on their footwear, but women? We are generally much more selective and appreciate a well-rounded group of color choices. I say give us some oranges and purples and yellows. Maybe even some heather gray.

Now that I’ve gotten that out, on to the important stuff.

Fit and Feel

If you’ve read my past reviews, you probably realize that I’m not one of those really smart technical reviewers who is hyper-focused on factors like weight or the differences between shoe materials. The way I see it, my feet don’t understand weight in tenths of ounces or know what EVA rubber is. They just know how it feels to land in the shoes I put on. They feel heat and cold, crunched and roomy, security and flexibility. And when I test a new shoe, I pay much more attention to what my feet tell me than all the stats that matter to the big-time shoe reviewers.

Maybe that’s just a girl thing. Or maybe it’s why I’m not a big-time shoe reviewer.

But I digress. I took my Breathos out walking instead of running for the first time, because I really wasn’t sure how I was going to like them. But the walk was fine and I learned that what I originally thought would be a width problem was no problem at all. The only thing is, I still haven’t figured out exactly how tight to lace them. The tongue of the shoe is attached to the rest of the upper (smart move) and is made of a moderately thin and breathable wicking fabric. So if I tie them too tight I can feel the lacing on my metatarsals even though the laces are spaced out really nicely, as if that decision was made in order to add comfort. But it wasn’t comfortable at all so I loosened them, and then the minute I started running they felt way too loose. My foot was sliding around because the mesh has so much give, much more like a sock than most of the other shoes Vivo offers. So I tightened them again and they held on to my foot better. After awhile I didn’t feel the laces as much anymore, but I still kept futzing with them unconsciously every couple of miles during my 14 miler the other day. This could have been a downfall of my wide feet, maybe most people with normal feet won’t have the same issue. but I’m curious to find out if they do.

Other than that I definitely liked the Breatho. I found them to be slick, form-fitting and true to size. Also a whole lot cooler (temperature-wise) to wear than the Neo Trail. And because they are so light, I consider the Breatho and the Neo Trail to be perfect summer and winter companions.

Side note: I have a tendency to run right through puddles rather than jumping over them (unlike normal people with brains). And since it’s still kind of chilly outside in mid-March, the Breathos didn’t dry right away and my toes got kind of cold afterward. Which will make them perfect for the summer! And they were dry in an hour or so – unlike the Neo Trails, which kept me warmer when wet but took several hours to dry.

I will say that I’ve resorted to keeping the insoles in these shoes, because I just don’t like the way the lugs feel on the balls of my feet and my toes. A soft sole equals more sensitivity, I guess. Gotta take the good with the bad.

Performance

I like to get dirty when I run.

Because they use the same sole, the Breatho’s trail performance is the same as the Neo Trail. The 4.5mm directional lugs cut through dirt, rocks and sand just as well, and I was pretty happy with that. I really, really like Vivo’s trail soles. I feel extremely confident and sure-footed on them. And I’m such a huge fan of the super flexibility – even though it gives up some protection, the way it curves around the terrain like a bare foot means the difference between a strong trail run and a bummer ankle sprain. Even if I have to take an occasional sharp rock to the arch of my foot.

Because I am training for a hilly 50k this spring, I have been tackling as many hills as I can find on my long runs. One thing I always hated about downhill running (besides my tendency to take them too fast and anger my IT band) was that my feet would always slip on rolling rocks and sand. In the Breatho I might still slip on the worst stuff, but it takes a lot more before it happens.

Price & Durability

I’m not entirely sure why, but the Breatho Trail is priced lower than almost the entire VIVOBAREFOOT shoe line. Maybe it’s that the lighter materials aren’t expected to last, or maybe Vivo decided to go easy on the price of this shoe in anticipation of its popularity. Either way I think it’s a decent price, and so far as I can see, worth it. They seem to be well constructed, for the most part.

The one thing I did notice happened to my particular pair is that after only a few wears there is some loosening of the stitching on the heel tag. I didn’t notice it right away, but I realized it after I took this picture.

I don’t remember using the tab to pull on the shoe, so I’m not sure how it even happened. Could have happened in production. But it looks like a surface flaw that probably won’t have any detrimental effects on the rest of the shoe, unless it starts to pull away at the fabric on the heel. But I’ll definitely check back in after a few hundred miles on these, and let you know how they last.

Conclusions

  • Beautifully crafted shoes that appeal to the sportier side of trail runners
  • Light, breathable and stretchy uppers that wear more like a sock than previous Vivo models
  • A good fit for warmer weather and climates
  • Flexible sole grabs onto the trails and provide excellent stability
  • Exceptional off-road traction that is on par with the popular Neo Trail
  • Rugged lacing can be a problem for some, against the soft fabric of the uppers
  • Color choices are a bit sparse on the women’s side
  • The price is nice, durability is to be seen.

And, my 14-Mile Run

And as a special addition to today’s review, I am adding some photos of my latest trail run in my Breatho Trails. Know why? Because these shoes got me through 14 MILES this weekend – my longest run. Ever. That’s worthy of a little celebration, don’t ya think?

Most of this trail is regrettably flat, but there are some hills. Unfortunately for you, I didn’t have the wherewithal to take photos while I was figuring out the hills.

Oscar is an excellent trail running partner. He’s always up ahead with this look like “well, are you coming or not?” Best dog in the world.

About these ads

31 thoughts on “Review: VIVOBAREFOOT Breatho Trail

  1. I’m with you on the colors. Merrell was the same way. What’s up with that? Don’t they see our colorful tutus out there???

  2. Nice review.. thanks Trisha! And congrats on the 14-miler… that is pure AWESOME!

    I’m dying to try these shoes out… I love my NEO Trails… but they are too warm to wear now that it is above 65 out…..

    • Thanks once again for reading, Jeff! Yes, the Breatho is definitely much less fabric and better for hot days.

      • Funny you say that but as a bloke the range of running gear seems really tame and dull compared to the ranges for women. As if men don’t like to run in bright eye catching colours and styles.

        (And thought the above was a really good review.)

      • Woot! Just got a pair of Breatho’s in! I picked the light/grey and red… something tells me they won’t stay this color very long.. especially with all the red dirt around here… any way, looking forward to working up a review too :-)

  3. Nice review – as a chap, I got the black/yellow combo pair – it’s like wearing bumble bees on your feet! Feel for you that there isn’t as much choice in the women’s sizes.

    I just tried my pair out for a quick 4km jaunt round a country park this morning, very nice feel to them, totally agree they’re like a sock, though I’ve got a good bit of transitioning to full-time barefoot yet.

  4. Will be sure to let you know – initial thoughts are up on my blog, pursuedbyangrybees.wordpress.com – would be interested in your views between Vivobarefoot and the Vibrams – was initially looking at those, but thought I might get stoned by the good people of the borough if I wore them out in public. :-)

  5. Which borough still stones people?! :p

    I wear my veebs out to the grocery store and other errands sometimes. I have come to enjoy the strange looks! But I get less of them lately because I think people are a little more desensitized to them these days.

  6. Pingback: Review: VIVOBAREFOOT Neo « Barefoot Monologues

  7. Pingback: Review: Vibram FiveFingers SeeYa « Barefoot Monologues

  8. Pingback: Review: INKnBURN Running Skirts « Barefoot Monologues

  9. I came across your blog the other day, looking for Breatho reviews. This is great! What size do you wear in the breathos? I read on here that you wear a size 39 bikila. I do too, and I also have wide feet. There aren’t any stores selling the breathos in my area, so I can’t try them on before ordering. Thanks!!

    • Thanks for reading, Natalie! Yep, size 39 should be fine in these if you’re comfy in a 39 Bikila. Let me know how you like them. And if you would be so kind as to get to their site by clicking on the banner to the right in this blog, it would be super appreciated.
      Happy running!

  10. Pingback: Review: VIVOBAREFOOT Ultra « Barefoot Monologues

  11. Pingback: Review: VIVOBAREFOOT Mary Jane « Barefoot Monologues

  12. Pingback: How to Find Your Mid-Foot « Barefoot Monologues

  13. Thanks for the review, I bought the shoe after reading. I’ve done about 150 miles in the last three weeks in them and have to say they are a really good shoe. I have a wide forefoot and have been struggling to find a comfortable minimalist shoe for the trail. I have been running in VFF’s on the trail until lately but find them a tad too sensitive on rocky trails at anything below 6 min mile pace. These are flexible and provide the needed proprioception but with just that bit more protection against the rocks. Great grip they can even cope with Scottish peat bogs to a certain extent. I want to wear the inov-8 bear grip 200 for my fell running but they are too narrow for my foot. These may be just the ticket for training runs in the hills but I’ve not tried them out yet, may not hold my foot securely enough on the steeper descents.

    • Oh, good! I’m glad you like them, Iain! Sounds like you’ve got some serious running for the Breathos, I’m happy to hear they have held up well for you. Thanks for reading!

  14. Pingback: Review: VIVOBAREFOOT Lucy Lite « Barefoot Monologues

  15. Really awesome review – thanks a lot! My wife is a Merell glove fan but they are slowly but surely on their way out. As I have to do all of her research and most of the shopping too (lucky me….!) I’ll be able to use your review to convince her to switch. She’s very loyal to Merell but concedes that the grip is slippy in the wet and wear/tear not ideal. Hopefully these vivos will be more robust? Thanks, and yes, I’ll definitely go onto their website via your link.

    • Well, it does depend on how she wore the merrells out. Was it the upper or the sole? Because the upper on the Vivo is quite soft and stretchy, it probably has no more robustness than the Merrell. But the sole is fantastic. It’s got those bold lugs and pierce-resistant sole. But the sole is softer and more pliable, and has no rock plate. So that’s something to consider.

  16. Good review, thanks. Do you know how these compare in size with the Merrell Trail Gloves?
    I’ve read that you need to go down a size for these Vivos’. I’m an 8 in the Merrells.
    How did you find them going over small rocky terrain, bit concerned that you may be able to feel too much when on rocky terrain.

    Thanks
    Jim

    • I wear the Pace Gloves, which are only slightly different, but I do find the Breathos to be slightly longer than the Pace Gloves. Then again, I think Pace Gloves tend to run a little short – I sometimes wish I had ordered a size up. With that said, I would order your regular size in the Breathos, and not go down a size, because you want to have a little extra room for your toes. You don’t want them smacking the edge of the shoe.

      You feel a little bit more with the Breathos than with the Trail Gloves. But because these happen to be my two favorite trail shoes, I would say that you’d do great to own both. The TG’s are excellent for rock protection, but the Breathos do their best with grip and proprioception. Whenever I’m not sure about a terrain I take my Breathos. Their extreme grip will keep you from sliding around and they actually protect you a bit from rocks, because the lugs are so huge they lift you up off hard surfaces a bit (like rocks).

      I mean hey, neither of these shoes are giving you much protection from the ground. But if you’re already dealing well with the very thin-to-nil rock protection of the TG, then the Breatho won’t be much behind it.

  17. Great thing about the breatho’s is that you can shove them in the washing machine when they get dirty! I love these shoes, I might have to get another pair in black though as my grey and blue shoes are suffering in the winter mud!

  18. I am curious to know how the lugs on your Breathos have held up over the year of wearing them. I had a pair of the Off-Road Hi-Top for Ladies and within a couple of weeks, the lugs began to break down until finally, they were gone in some spots.

    The company sent me a replacement pair but it happened again with them. When I spoke to them a second time, they told me they now knew there problems and that the 2013 trail shoes with lugs would use a different chemical formula and would not break down.

    I see no reviews yet of these new soles anywhere online. Do you have any information on this issue?

    • Hi Wynne, thanks for reading. I have not experienced any significant wear of the lugs on my Breathos. It could be the terrain (typically quite soft dirt and rocks), my form/stride, or the fact that I rotate them with several other trail shoes (being a shoe reviewer will do that to you). Also, I have personally found that I don’t like wearing my Breathos on any pavement, so if I think my run will be partly on roads, I choose a different shoe. I find that the Breatho is very terrain-specific, and I wouldn’t make it the only trail shoe in my closet. But thank you for the information, I will pay attention to how they wear and maybe even post a second review on them, if I notice it happens to me too. Best of luck!

  19. I should add one more thing to my comment above. The company told me this problem was a result of my walking on pavement and that these soles are meant for dirt trails only. But how can one be expected to not be on pavement a lot of the time?

  20. Hi Trish. Thanks for the fast reply. I have a question about sizing of vivobarefoot shoes and it occurred to me that perhaps you can help me out since you seem to be somewhat of an expert on the topic. I don’t live near a store that sells these shoes (so must order online) and am concerned about width. My previous vivobarefoot shoes have all been quite wide but I am seeing more and more comments about how some styles are more narrow than expected. I am looking at either getting the Evo Lite Hydrophobic Ladies or the Neo Ladies. Usually I take a 37 but am wondering if I should be ordering a 38 just to make sure I get the necessary width. Any thoughts on this? Thanks.

    • I haven’t tried the Evo Lite but I have the Evo II. That is their narrowest shoe. The Neo is an excellent shoe, maybe their best. I have done a review of it on here (as well as the Evo II). You absolutely don’t have to worry about width on the Neo. But get a half size up from your usual, because the shoe tends to run a tad short.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 325 other followers